How Construction Trust Claims Differ from Liens
While construction liens create security interests against improved property, trust provisions create completely different obligations by establishing statutory trusts over project funds. These trust provisions serve as a critical complement to lien rights, especially in situations where:
- Lien rights have expired due to missed deadlines
- Project property has insufficient value to satisfy lien claims
- Multiple competing lien claims exceed available holdback funds
- The project's ownership structure complicates lien enforcement
- A contractor or subcontractor has become insolvent
At Belsito Law, we leverage trust remedies alongside other legal options to maximize recovery potential in construction payment disputes, creating comprehensive strategies that protect your financial interests through multiple legal avenues.
Understanding Construction Trust Obligations
The Construction Act establishes several types of trust relationships that impose strict obligations on those who receive and handle construction project funds:
Owner Trust Obligations
Property owners who receive loan advances or funds specifically for project financing must hold these amounts in trust for the contractor. This means these funds cannot be diverted to other purposes - they must be applied to project costs and contractor payments.
Contractor and Subcontractor Trust Obligations
When contractors and subcontractors receive payment for work performed on a project, they become trustees over these funds for the benefit of:
- Subcontractors and suppliers who supplied services or materials
- Workers who provided labour to the project
- The Workplace Safety and Insurance Board
- Any person entitled to payment under a contract or subcontract
These trust obligations require proper fund management and prevent the diversion of project payments away from those who contributed to the work.
Vendor Trust Obligations
When an owner sells improved property, a portion of the sale proceeds attributable to improvements may be subject to trust obligations for the benefit of contractors who weren't fully paid. This can create continuing liability even after property transfer.
These trust relationships impose fiduciary duties that go beyond normal contractual obligations, creating heightened responsibilities for proper financial management.
Personal Liability: A Powerful Recovery Tool
Perhaps the most significant aspect of construction trust claims is their ability to pierce the corporate veil and create personal liability for directors, officers, and other individuals who participate in a breach of trust. This personal liability means that recovery may be possible even when:
- The corporate entity has filed for bankruptcy
- Corporate assets have been depleted
- The business has been dissolved or abandoned
- Multiple corporate entities were used to shield assets
This powerful remedy distinguishes trust claims from many other construction recovery options and can be the difference between receiving payment and writing off losses when a payor becomes insolvent.
To establish personal liability, we demonstrate that individuals:
- Were directors, officers, or controlling minds of the corporation
- Had control over or direction of trust funds
- Participated in or assented to the misapplication of those funds
With four decades of experience in construction trust litigation, our team has developed effective strategies for tracing funds and establishing the elements necessary for personal liability claims.
Common Breaches of Construction Trust
Construction trust violations take many forms. Our practice regularly addresses situations where trustees improperly:
Divert Project Funds to Other Projects
One common violation occurs when contractors use funds from one project to pay expenses on entirely different projects. This "robbing Peter to pay Paul" approach creates a breach of trust even if the contractor intends to eventually rectify the situation.
Pay General Business Expenses
Trust funds must be applied to project-specific obligations, not general business overhead, administrative costs, or operational expenses unrelated to the specific improvement. Using project payments for rent, equipment loans, or general payroll typically constitutes a breach.
Make Shareholder Distributions
Paying dividends, bonuses, or making other distributions to company owners while project participants remain unpaid represents a clear trust violation that frequently results in personal liability.
Prefer Certain Creditors Over Beneficiaries
When trust funds are insufficient to pay all beneficiaries, the trustee must respect the trust relationship rather than paying other creditors first. Choosing to pay suppliers on other projects or non-construction creditors ahead of trust beneficiaries constitutes a breach.
Fail to Maintain Proper Accounting
The Construction Act imposes record-keeping requirements regarding trust funds. Failure to maintain proper accounting of these funds can itself be evidence of breach, even without direct proof of misappropriation.
Recognizing these patterns allows our legal team to identify breaches of trust and build compelling cases for recovery.
Our Approach to Construction Trust Claims
Effective trust claim litigation requires both specialized legal knowledge and practical industry understanding. Our process typically includes:
Comprehensive Initial Assessment
We begin by analyzing payment documentation, project contracts, corporate structures, and financial flows to identify potential trust violations and recovery options. This assessment establishes whether trust claims offer advantages over other remedies and identifies potential personally liable parties.
Strategic Demand and Negotiation
Before commencing formal proceedings, we often issue detailed demand correspondence outlining the trust obligations and personal liability risks. This approach frequently motivates resolution, as individuals facing personal liability recognize the significant risks of litigation.
Targeted Discovery and Financial Investigation
When litigation becomes necessary, we conduct focused examinations and financial discovery to trace trust funds and establish breach elements. Our experience in construction trust litigation allows us to efficiently identify key evidence demonstrating misapplication of funds.
Coordinated Claims Strategy
Where appropriate, we coordinate trust claims with other remedies, including:
- Construction lien proceedings
- Bond claims under labour and material payment bonds
- Contract actions for unpaid amounts
- Prompt payment adjudication proceedings
This multi-faceted approach maximizes recovery potential while applying strategic pressure through various legal channels.
Preventative Trust Compliance Guidance
Beyond litigation, we help construction industry clients establish proper trust fund management systems to avoid inadvertent breaches and personal liability. This guidance includes:
For Contractors and Subcontractors
We assist in establishing compliant financial controls, including:
- Project-specific accounting systems
- Proper fund segregation protocols
- Payment application procedures
- Documentation of trust fund disposition
- Corporate governance safeguards
These preventative measures protect both the business and its directors/officers from trust violation claims.
For Owners and Developers
We advise on proper funding distribution and management, including:
- Appropriate contractual provisions regarding trust obligations
- Protocols for managing construction loan advances
- Systems for tracking improvement funds
- Documentation of payment disbursements
This guidance helps prevent inadvertent trust violations while establishing evidence of compliance.
When to Consider Construction Trust Claims
Trust remedies should be evaluated when:
- Payment is significantly delayed despite project progress
- The payor appears to be experiencing financial distress
- Other projects by the same contractor face payment issues
- Lien rights have expired or may be insufficient for recovery
- The contractor has ceased operations or filed for bankruptcy
- Project funds appear to have been diverted to other purposes
Early evaluation of trust claim options often provides the best chance for recovery, particularly when financial distress signals appear.
The Belsito Advantage in Trust Litigation
Construction trust litigation requires specialized knowledge and experience that general litigation firms often lack. When you choose Belsito Law for your trust claim, you benefit from:
Focused Construction Industry Expertise
Our four decades of construction law experience provide practical insight into industry practices, payment flows, and financial management standards - context that proves invaluable in trust litigation.
Technical Financial Analysis
We work effectively with accounting evidence and financial documentation to trace funds and establish breach elements, often without requiring costly external forensic accounting.
Balanced Perspective
Having represented parties on both sides of trust claims, we understand the concerns and defenses raised by trustees, allowing us to anticipate and counter opposition strategies effectively.
Strategic Enforcement
We develop targeted approaches based on the specific facts of your situation, maximizing recovery potential while managing legal costs appropriately.
Contact Belsito Law for Construction Trust Claim Expertise
If you've provided labour, services, or materials to a construction project and haven't received proper payment, trust remedies may provide recovery options beyond traditional lien claims. The experienced construction trust litigation team at Belsito Law offers the specialized knowledge needed to pursue these claims effectively.
For contractors, subcontractors, and suppliers throughout Richmond Hill, Woodbridge, North York, Vaughan, and surrounding areas, we provide strategic guidance on construction trust rights and remedies. Our comprehensive approach evaluates all available recovery options to develop the most effective strategy for your specific situation.
Don't write off construction losses without exploring all available remedies. Contact Belsito Law today to discuss how construction trust claims might help recover payment even in challenging circumstances.
Schedule Your Consultation Today
